#177: The Case of the
Original Airdate: 04/11/63
From The Perry Mason TV Show Book
This is another story of partners who don’t trust each other. Austin Lloyd and Dwight Garrett are partners in a reliability testing firm. But Garrett wants out when he learns that Lloyd is swindling a large aerospace company.
Faced with the dissolution of the partnership and knowing that his wife Bonnie is in love with Garrett, Lloyd plans to fake a poisoning attempt on his life, making it look as though Garrett and Bonnie tried to kill him so they could run away to Mexico. But Lloyd really does die. Perry is convinced that Garrett is innocent.
Starring Raymond Burr
in The Case of THE ELUSIVE ELEMENT
Based upon characters created by Erle Stanley Gardner
Barbara Hale, William Hopper, William Talman, Ray Collins
Directed by Harmon Jones
Written by Samuel Newman
Art Seid | Producer
Gail Patrick Jackson | Executive Producer
Jackson Gillis | Associate Producer
Samuel Newman | Story Consultant
Raymond Burr as Perry Mason
Barbara Hale as Della Street
William Hopper as Paul Drake
Wiliam Talman as Hamilton Burger
Ray Collins as Lt. Tragg
Wesley Lau as Lt. Anderson
Gloria Talbott as Bonnie Lloyd
Gerald Mohr as Austin Lloyd
Douglas Henderson as Dwight Garrett
George Macready as Roscoe Pearce
Douglas Dick as Ned Chase
Ronald Long as Myron Baker
Elaine Devry as Terry Clover
S. John Launer as Judge
Jon Lormer as Autopsy Surgeon
Tommy Farrell as Robert Fordney
Billy Halop as Man
Ollie O’Toole as Grocery Clerk
Ray Dannis as Radio Salesman
Michael Harris as Sgt. Bruce
Guy Standing III as Airline Clerk
Harry Fleer as Bank Teller
- Maître d’Hôtel
- Bank Customer
- Courtroom Extra
Director of Photography … Robert G. Hager
Art Direction … Lewis Creber
Assistant Director … Gordon A. Webb
Film Editor … John D. Faure
Casting … Harvey Clermont
Makeup … Irving Pringle
Hair Stylist … Annabell
Wardrobe Supervision … Ed McDermott, Evelyn Carruth
Set Decoration … Sandy Grace
Properties … Ray Thompson
Production Sound Mixer … Herman Lewis
Script Supervision … Cosmo Genovese
Theme Composed by … Fred Steiner
Produced by the CBS Television Network in association with Paisano Productions
This is the only episode with co-defendants. jfh 13Mar2017.
+ Actually, no: (what is believed to be) the very first episode - TCOT Motheaten Mink - featured them as well. Commented by Notcom, 031417.
++ Also, to correct my initial statement: In The Case Of The Sausalito Sunrise Perry represents another set of co-defendants. jfh 30Mar2017.
In the office, after the first scene in court, Perry reveals some poetic depth and doth quote “I am a little world made cunningly of elements.” This is from Holy Sonnet V by John Donne. Submitted by Steve Fox, 12/22/2004.
Location: About 19 minutes in, there is a quick shot of Los Angeles International Airport with a glimpse of the Googie styled “Theme Building.” It looks like a space-aged bug or flying saucer on legs. I have read it was the inspiration for buildings in the cartoon The Jetsons. I have eaten at the cool eatery at the top called the Encounter Restaurant. Also appears in episode #198. Submitted by Eric Cooper, 10 June 10. Some pictures here.
+ The Perry shots of the Airport Theme Bldg. are Aerial & Far-away; the "Dear Mummy" episode of Quincy shows the Space-Age building from a Ground-level, Close-up Perspective [1981: IMDb]. Mike Bedard 4.28.15
The man trying to cash the check in the grocery store is Billy Halop, who died fairly young. His alcoholism stalled his career, and when he died he had already left acting for nursing. Perhaps he is best known as the recurring cabdriver on All in the Family. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
+ I will always remember him as one of the Dead End Kids (also mentioned in notes to episiode 153). Added by H. Mason 2/10/15
++ LA's fastest altho a necessary - or at least a useful - plot point, his apprehension by the police was ridulously fast: only if they were literally right outside the door would they arrive that quickly. Notcom 061622.
Sightings: At the supermarket, “Miss Carmody” is in the aisle behind Austin Lloyd’s, checking out her groceries with a a large handbag and a smile and a few nods. After an incident in the store, she is rather perturbed and talks rather excitedly to the clerk. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
+ During the hearing, the Pencil Mustache Man lurks among the other spectators, but is never quite clearly shown. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011. See below for uncredited actors (with names) also seated in the gallery.
There is a "Sergeant Parnell, special agent", but we only see the back of his head. Added by BobwloCB, 1/2/2015.
Uncredited Actors: Bert Stevens is the maître d’hôtel at the restaurant where Garrett and Mrs. Lloyd meet. We also see a great deal of Stevens in the courtroom gallery (he’s in several cutaways). Another who appears without billing in the gallery is the prolific character actor Joseph Crehan, whom we don’t yet have on our Uncredited Actors page. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
+ Stevens also appears as a customer at the bank where Mrs. Lloyd cashes a check. And character actor Ralph Brooks, although he never speaks, plays Burger’s co-counsel at the hearing. Submitted by gracenote, 7/28/2011.
S[aul] John Launer was in 33 PMs (12.1% as Judges: 1958-66), 6 Dragnets (1 Chief, 2 Deputy Chief) & 5 FBIs [IMDb]. Mike Bedard 2.11.15
As the sign reads on the cash register at the supermarket, Telecredit provides the electronic check approval. This was a real L.A. company, incorporated in 1961. Equifax bought it out, and now the check approval is done by Certegy. Submitted by gracenote, 7/28/2011.
+ Indeed, Telecredit consumer check verification was founded by Ronald Katz in 1961. Mr. Katz is the son of late musician and comedian Mickey Katz, brother of Academy Award winning actor Joel Grey, and uncle to actress and Dirty Dancing star Jennifer Grey. Submitted by Mason Jar 9/15/2011.
Typing: At time 5:41 into the DVD of this episode, Austin Lloyd’s secretary Terry Clover (played by Elaine Devry) is seated at her desk typing. But after the salutation of the letter, when you look under the typewriter bail, you see she is just typing ”asdfghjkl;asdfghjkl;asdfghjkl;“ over and over. See picture here. Submitted by Charles Richmond, 11/23/2011.
+ I wish that this shot was in the broadcast rerun that I've seen! According to the later courtroom testimony, her typewriter should be the white (or very light-coloured) Selectric. The broadcast rerun does have a scene in Dwight's restricted-access office that shows the dark-coloured Selectric (in accordance with the later evidence).
"DIMOS" (pronounced DEE-MOSS) is the "10-year long range space project" that the companies are competing for. Roscoe tells Perry that DIMOS stands for "Delta Interplanetary Manned Orbital Satellite". The acronym can also be seen later on the project binder held by Ned in Perry's office. Added by Gary Woloski, 12/23/12.
+ It could also be a clever play on the word "Deimos," which is one of the moons of Mars. Submitted by 65tosspowertrap, 10/21/2013.
++ Not to be (too) nitpicky, DIMOS is the "Delta Interplanetary Manned OrbitING Satellite", the implication being that Mars is the planet that is the destination. And since the acronym is being pronounced exactly the same as the moon Deimos (dee-mohss), I think it is safe to say that Mars was indeed the target. There were obviously issues with the project that cropped up after the episode was broadcast, since we still haven't put people in orbit around Mars ;-) OLEF641 6/2/21
Two Background Cars, no Cast Cars. There are fleeting glimpses of just two vehicles:
- (a) When Austin Lloyd goes to the liquor/deli mart, the Right-Rear side of a parked car is visible through the "OUT" door: watch while the cops nab the check-bouncing Man at 05:24. What you see is almost certainly this, part of a light-color 1963 Mercury Meteor Custom.
- (b) A 1957 Plymouth Savoy 4-Door Sedan approaches the LA airport “Theme Building” at 18:47. The episode car's 2-tone paint looks the same as that on the car in the linked image. Identify make & year by the distinctive fin/taillight combination; sharper images here & here.
It appears that Car (b) doesn't have the new '63-issue black-plate. Exactly the same shot opens the next episode and it's clear there that the car still has the old plate. Added by Gary Woloski, 9/21/13.
The changeable ball was a key feature of the legendary IBM Selectric Typewriter. It may have been new to people during this time so the element aspect may not be common knowledge. They were never cheap. You can even see the IBM logo during the court scene. Submitted by Perry Baby 7/29/16.
+ I noticed the IBM logo on the typewriter too, very prominent. There is also a computer in the episode (presumably an IBM too), so I wonder if this was product placement for IBM. —yelocab 05APR18
+ If you're referring to the punched cards being sorted, and then Dwight Garrett taking one out to look at, this was not a computer, it was just a card sorter. Submitted by Clothears, 21-Jan-2022.
This is the second of three PM appearances for Elaine Devry, who was born in Compton CA and was married to Mickey Rooney from 1952-1958...MikeM. 12/5.2016
This is the third of four PM appearances for Gloria Talbott, who was born and died in the LA suburb of Glendale...MikeM. 3/13/2017
Wheels within Wheels: After watching this episode, I began to ask myself "Why do so many plot elements in Perry Mason stories seem to repeat themselves?". One reason is Erle Stanley Gardner's use of "plot wheels" as discussed in blog.karenwoodward.org/2013/10/nanowrimo-erle-stanley-gardner-perry-mason-plot-wheels.html.
At one time Gardner used 4 such wheels to help him in plotting and to make it less likely that he would repeat himself too often. The wheels used by Gardner each had about 16 choices on each one, which were turned at random in advance of writing, resulting in 65,536 possible plots.
The weakness in this was that with only 16 choices for each wheel - which variously represented Red Herrings, Complications, Obstacles and Solutions - one of the sixteen parameters of each wheel would recur in each story, only in 64K different combinations. To get down to cases, take this episode, show #177. Although not credited to Gardner, he did have a strong influence on the selection and adaptation of scripts. On his plot wheel number 4 ("Solutions") parameter #6 is "villain hoist by own petard", and parameter #7 is "villain killed while trying to frame someone". Which is exactly the solution to this episode's mystery. This solution also occurs in Perry Mason novel TCOT Runaway Corpse, and in TV episode TCOT Frantic Flyer, as well as in other Gardner books - for example "Pass the Gravy"- a Bertha Cool / Donald Lam novel - where a husband and wife conspire to defraud an insurance company by killing a derelict and then abandoning his body together with the husband's wallet and papers, in a lonely place where identification would soon become impossible. But the husband gets cold feet at the last moment and the wife suddenly realises that if she kills her husband for real, she can have all the insurance for herself. Written by cspoleta on 3-13-17
This is the second of five PM directing credits for Canadian-born Harmon Jones, who was nominated for an Academy Award for film editing in 1947. His son and granddaughter would also later be nominated for Academy Awards for film editing...MikeM. 4/2/2018
This episode is old home week for Perry Mason alumni. Of the top 7 actors listed, the fewest PM appearances is 3 and the most is 7.
Talbert - 4, Mohr-4, Henderson -6, Macready-4, Dick-7, Long-3, Devry-3. DaveH 12/21/18
+ Also, Billy Halop was in three PM episodes, this was his second. OLEF641 6/2/21
Music Maestro, Please: at 10:02, in the restaurant, with Dwight and Bonnie, we hear Johann Strauss's famous waltz, "Tales from the Vienna Woods" ("Geschichten aus dem Wienerwald") which premiered in 1868 and was dedicated to his Highness Prince Constantin Hohenlohe-Schillingsfürst (1828-1896). The selection used starts at around 3 1/4 minutes into the 12-minute composition. I have no idea what it is doing here, but i like it a lot. Submitted by catyron, July 31st, 2021.
The electronic check company claimed that it had a database of "every driver's license number in the state" that it used to verify whether a check was good. In a pre-Internet world, not sure how a private company would have access to that information without just cause. Seems like a violation of privacy rights. And how can a driver's license number verify whether a check is good or not? If the driver's license numbers are tied to people's bank accounts, that means the check company would also have access to their banking information. Again, it seems like a gross violation of privacy laws. Even if they did have all that information, they certainly wouldn't be able to tell whether an account had the money in it at the moment the check was presented or if the account was even still open. The check cashing guy bragged that it takes 4 seconds to verify the check is good, but all we saw was long wait times on the phone while customers got very impatient. Even the phone call to the cops had to have taken longer than 4 seconds due to the way the phones worked back then. Guess they hadn't figured out a way to link the verification data to actual cash registers yet. How was this quicker than just simply calling the bank to verify the check was good? Seems like false advertising. Submitted by DellaMason 12/1/23
Shades of 1957s Desk Set starring Katharine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy, she a reference librarian and he an efficiency expert with computer punchcards, whose "socks don't always match." jfh 23Dec2023
Hooray, it’s the second Space Age story in a row (Aerospace Reliability Associates is the firm), and yet somewhat noir-ish, especially with Bogie-wannabe Gerald Mohr in a major role. Macready gives the whole thing some gravitas, but I would have liked to have seen more of him. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
I have to add that I just love the technology in this episode, especially the electronic check verification. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
+ The enlargements that Burger later presents in court indicate that the checks were also perforated to thwart alteration, a form of check protection technology dating from the 1800s. A dot-matrix “3” and other perforated characters can be seen - somewhat like this , made by the Abbott Automatic Check Protector, patented 1889. More antique “physical check protection” here. Added by Gary Woloski, 11/30/11.
For the umpteenth time this season, Ray Collins gets credit for playing Tragg, but does not actually appear. Submitted by gracenote, 2/2/2011.
Perry wears three different collar types. Early in the show, he's wearing a collar tie. He switches to a button-down collar. By the courtroom scene and the ending, he's wearing a spread collar. Otto Gervaert, 1/18/21.>>?
Gerald Mohr plays Austin Lloyd. Lloyd Austin is the current U.S. Secretary of Defense. Otto Gervaert, 2/17/23.
The opening shot is of the California Spruce Medical Building at 500 Spruce Street in San Francisco (see for example Google maps), but the shot continues on to the sign for Aerospace Reliability Associates, which is at 653 N. Sixth Street in Los Angeles (per the “asdfgh…” letter that Miss Clover is typing). Submitted by masonite, 12/01/2011.
+ The addresses in the show often feature (what people call) inside jokes: using the studio on Las Palmas, or something otherwise connected with the show. That wouldn't work for what is supposed to be a downtown location, but how to come up with something plausible?? The solution was simple (and clever): like many cities in the U.S. Los Angeles uses the Philadelphia System for its streets - streets are numbered if they run in one direction, but named if they run orthogonally; but unlike the original, in L.A. the numbered streets run east/west...so N(orth) Sixth Street doesn't exist. A remarkable attention to detail. Notcom, 060221
Oh, that Gloria Talbott ... those eyes!! Submitted by MikeReese, 12/13/2013.
Elementary?: Perry learned, at 23:25 on the 2011 Paramount DVD, that it was very quick and easy to switch typewriter elements so as to get a different character set. Also present were Terry Clover and Roscoe Pearce. Why, then, did the later preliminary hearing need to take 9+ minutes of episode time trying to "prove" which typewriter did which typing? Perry could have easily shown early on that Hamilton was actually proving nothing. Further, given that the DA's office and LAPD were also using typewriters, someone in either office also surely knew about the ridiculousness of the point that Hamilton was trying to prove. Scriptwriter Samuel Newman had a clever gimmick with the electronic check approval, then seemed to me to overly pad his script with the typing nonsense. Luckily for Dwight Garrett, Bonnie Lloyd liked his type. lowercase masonite, 3/4/16.
+ "I am a little world made cunningly of elements," Perry says, quoting John Donne's "Holy Sonnets." Mike Bedard 7.9.16.
+ The typewriters are a matched pair of IBM Selectrics. This line was first introduced in 1961. The font spheres which IBM officially called "typing elements" were generally called "type balls" or "golf balls" by those who used them. I was one such user, more than 50 years ago, and i also learned typesetting on the same company's high-end proportional-width-font machine, the IBM Selectric Composer. Read more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Selectric_typewriter Submitted by catyron, May 11, 2018
The Telecredit reports shown when Bonnie Lloyd is buying the airline tickets and when she is buying the radio are identical. The report lists several names but not hers. The last name typed, Harry Paxtin, appears to have a fraudulent license. Submitted by Kilo 8/19/2018.
The Typewriter Evidence. With Lt Anderson on the stand, Burger presents enlarged specimens of legitimate and bogus Project Reports and cheques to show on which of two typewriters they were produced. The typewriters, also in court, are IBM Selectrics (electric typewriters introduced 1961). The Selectric was then unique in having a fixed carriage (paper holder) and a laterally moving printing element (a rotating “type ball”). Read about the Selectric here. How it works here (3:05 video). Selectric Museum here (In the top image at this link, the larger, square-shaped machines in the pile are mostly Selectric IIs [intro 1971]; one blue Selectric III [intro 1980] is at bottom right).
- Burger and Anderson remain totally unaware of the innovative features of the Selectric until midway through Perry’s cross-examination of Anderson. Until that point, everyone in the courtroom but Perry thinks that Selectrics are just run-of-the-mill typewriters.
- I'm sure I heard the motor start to whir when Lt Anderson initially touched the first machine. I think that there must have been a microphone specially placed to capture this sound. Well Done!
- When Lt. Anderson types his comparison texts at Perry’s urging, you can see that the carriage is stationary and, if you watch very closely, you may catch a glimpse of the type ball moving across the page. The IBM logo plate on the top deck is well shown several times.
- When Perry quickly and expertly demonstrates how to exchange the elements, Anderson and Burger are confounded and struck speechless.
- The typeface in the courtroom enlargements appears to be “Adjutant“ (this shows a generic Adjutant font). Some ID points: prominent serifs, the numeral for “three,” shallow “v” in the capital “M.” A sample of the genuine IBM Selectric Adjutant is here.
- The passage in the original “DIMOS” Reliability Report presented by Burger reads “therefore, the trade off analysis juxtaposing size, weight, and strength clearly indicates MIL - Q - 34D2b will be required for the structural frame of the payload package.” In the bogus substitute report, the "b" in the MIL-Q designator has been replaced with a "c". A "MIL-Q" would have been a Department of Defense Quality Standard.
If you have an old Selectric in the basement, you may wish to check out the Yahoo Golf ball typewriter shop. With assistance from David Sadowski, Yahoo! Typewriter Group. Added by Gary Woloski, 11/28/11.
The gimmick of switching the element only makes sense in the unlikely case someone was aware of a distinctive difference between them. DOD 01/03/20
Lt. Anderson didn't type nearly enough letters to reflect the text that was shown on the sheet of paper he showed. —yelocab 05APR18
...and to type that line of letter N, he need only have held down the N key. DOD 01/18/21